For most Manhattan residents, the single most expensive asset they own is not stock or even a co-op apartment — it is the cost of a nursing home, which in New York County routinely exceeds $190,000 per year, and Medicaid will count nearly everything you own before it pays a dollar. This is the surprising reality that drives interest in irrevocable trusts in Manhattan: properly structured, an irrevocable trust can hold your apartment and savings outside the reach of long-term-care creditors and estate taxes, but the price of that protection is real and permanent. You must genuinely give up control. This guide explains how Medicaid asset protection trusts (MAPTs) and irrevocable life insurance trusts (ILITs) work under New York law, the five-year lookback that governs the timing, and the trade-offs every Manhattanite should weigh before signing.
What Makes a Trust “Irrevocable” Under New York Law
A revocable living trust can be amended or torn up at will; an irrevocable trust generally cannot. Once you transfer your co-op shares, brownstone, or brokerage account into an irrevocable trust, the trust — not you — owns the asset. New York’s Estate Powers and Trusts Law governs these instruments, and EPTL § 7-1.9 sets the one major escape hatch: an irrevocable trust may be revoked or amended only with the written, acknowledged consent of every person beneficially interested in it. In practice, that means your children and any other beneficiaries must all agree, which is precisely why these trusts are treated as a true relinquishment of control.
That relinquishment is the whole point. Because you no longer own the asset, it is shielded from your future creditors, it can fall outside your taxable estate, and — when drafted as a MAPT — it stops counting against you for Medicaid eligibility. The protection flows directly from the loss of control. A trust you can undo at any time protects you from nothing.
Grantor vs. Non-Grantor Status
Most asset protection trusts in Manhattan are drafted as “grantor trusts” for income-tax purposes. This is a deliberate choice. By retaining a limited power — such as the right to receive trust income, or a power of substitution under Internal Revenue Code § 675 — the grantor keeps the trust’s income taxed on their own 1040 at personal rates rather than the steep compressed trust brackets. Critically, retaining the right to live in the home and direct who ultimately inherits also preserves the full IRC § 121 capital-gains exclusion ($250,000 single / $500,000 married) and the stepped-up cost basis at death, while still keeping the asset out of the Medicaid calculation.
The Medicaid Asset Protection Trust (MAPT)
The MAPT is the workhorse of elder-law planning in New York County. Its job is to move the family home and liquid savings out of your name so that, after a waiting period, they no longer count toward Medicaid’s strict asset limits for nursing-home care. You typically retain the right to live in the residence for life and to receive trust income, but you give up the principal — you cannot pull the apartment back out and sell it for cash in your own pocket.
The Five-Year Lookback
Timing is everything. When you apply for institutional (nursing-home) Medicaid in New York, the agency reviews your financial records for the 60 months immediately preceding the application — the “five-year lookback.” Any uncompensated transfer to an irrevocable trust during that window creates a penalty period of ineligibility, calculated by dividing the transferred amount by the regional monthly nursing-home rate set by the state. The lesson is blunt: a MAPT funded today protects nothing if you enter a nursing home next year, but fully protects the assets once five clean years have passed.
New York has long applied this 60-month lookback to institutional care. Note an important 2026 distinction: community-based long-term care (home care under Managed Long Term Care) is on its own implementation track for a lookback in New York, separate from the established 60-month institutional rule. Because the rules and effective dates here continue to shift, this is an area where current guidance from counsel matters more than last year’s article.
What Goes Into a MAPT — and What Should Not
- Good candidates: the primary residence (co-op, condo, or townhouse), non-retirement brokerage accounts, savings, and a rental property you do not need to liquidate.
- Keep out: IRAs and 401(k)s — transferring these triggers immediate income tax on the full balance. They are usually handled through beneficiary designations instead.
- Watch the co-op: Manhattan co-op boards must approve the transfer of shares into a trust, and many boards have specific trust requirements or refuse outright. This is a Manhattan-specific hurdle that can derail an otherwise sound plan.
The Irrevocable Life Insurance Trust (ILIT)
An ILIT solves a different problem: estate tax. New York has its own estate tax with a 2026 exemption near $7.16 million per individual and a notorious “cliff” — exceed the exemption by more than 5% and the entire estate, not just the excess, becomes taxable. For a Manhattan family whose apartment alone may be worth several million dollars, a large life-insurance death benefit paid into the taxable estate can be exactly what pushes them over that cliff.
The fix is to have an ILIT own the policy. Because the trust — not the insured — owns and is the beneficiary of the policy, the death benefit is excluded from the insured’s taxable estate at both the New York and federal levels, while still delivering tax-free liquidity to the family. That cash can be used to pay estate taxes, equalize inheritances among children, or buy out a sibling’s share of the family home without a fire sale. To learn how the underlying tax math works, see our overview of New York and federal estate taxes.
An ILIT’s three-year rule (IRC § 2035) means that if you transfer an existing policy into the trust, you must survive three years for the death benefit to escape your estate. New policies bought directly by the trustee avoid this trap entirely.
The Real Trade-Off: Comparing the Tools
No irrevocable trust is free. Each one trades a measure of control or flexibility for a specific protection. The table below frames the decision the way we frame it for clients at the kitchen table.
| Feature | Revocable Living Trust | MAPT (Irrevocable) | ILIT (Irrevocable) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Can you change or revoke it? | Yes, anytime | No (only via EPTL § 7-1.9 consent) | No |
| Protects from Medicaid spend-down? | No | Yes, after 5-year lookback | No |
| Removes assets from NY taxable estate? | No | Generally yes | Yes (insurance proceeds) |
| Preserves step-up in basis at death? | Yes | Yes, if drafted as grantor trust | N/A (insurance) |
| Avoids Manhattan probate? | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Primary purpose | Probate avoidance + control | Long-term-care protection | Estate-tax liquidity |
One shared benefit worth noting: assets held in any properly funded trust pass outside of probate, sparing your family the delay and cost of a proceeding in the New York County Surrogate’s Court. If you want to understand what your heirs avoid, review our explanation of the Manhattan probate process and the role of the Surrogate’s Court at 31 Chambers Street.
Concrete Manhattan Scenarios
The Upper West Side Co-op Owner
Eleanor, 71, owns a paid-off co-op on West End Avenue worth $1.9 million and has $400,000 in savings. Her goal is to protect the apartment from a future nursing-home spend-down and leave it to her daughter. We establish a MAPT, secure co-op board approval for the share transfer, and fund the trust. Eleanor retains a life estate interest, keeps paying maintenance and her STAR exemption, and preserves the basis step-up. If she needs care after 2031, the apartment is fully protected; if she needs it in 2028, only a partial penalty applies.
The Tribeca Family Facing the Estate-Tax Cliff
David and Mei own a Tribeca loft worth $4.5 million, a brokerage account of $3 million, and David carries a $3 million term-to-permanent life policy. Together, this sits comfortably over New York’s roughly $7.16M-per-person threshold and risks the cliff. By having a new ILIT purchase the coverage, the $3 million death benefit lands outside the taxable estate, giving Mei tax-free cash to cover the New York estate tax bill without selling the loft.
- Identify the goal first — care protection (MAPT) or tax liquidity (ILIT) drives the structure.
- Inventory and value assets, including any Manhattan co-op or condo and its board rules.
- Draft the trust with the right grantor powers to preserve basis and the IRC § 121 exclusion.
- Fund it correctly — an unfunded trust protects nothing.
- Start the lookback clock as early as possible.
Common Mistakes Manhattan Families Make
- Waiting too long. Families often consider a MAPT only after a health crisis, when the five-year clock cannot possibly run in time.
- Putting retirement accounts into the trust, triggering a large, avoidable income-tax bill.
- Ignoring the co-op board. Transferring shares without board approval can violate the proprietary lease.
- Naming the wrong trustee. The grantor cannot serve as trustee of their own MAPT without undermining the protection; an adult child or independent trustee is typically required.
- Failing to fund the trust. A signed but empty trust is just paper. The deed, shares, or accounts must actually be retitled.
- Using a one-size-fits-all online form that ignores New York’s EPTL drafting requirements and the estate-tax cliff.
When to Call a Manhattan Estate-Planning Attorney
Irrevocable trusts are powerful but unforgiving — a drafting error or a mistimed transfer can cost a family the very asset they meant to protect, and unlike a revocable plan, it cannot simply be undone. If you own a Manhattan co-op or condo, are within a decade of potential long-term-care needs, or sit near New York’s estate-tax cliff, this is not a do-it-yourself project. A qualified estate planning attorney in NYC can model the lookback timing, coordinate the co-op board approval, and draft the grantor powers that preserve your basis and tax exclusions. For the official New York estate-tax framework, you can also consult the New York State Department of Taxation and Finance.
The right time to plan is while you are healthy and the five-year clock can still run in your favor. In Manhattan, where a single apartment can represent a lifetime of wealth, the difference between a trust signed in 2026 and one signed too late can be the difference between leaving a legacy and spending it all on care.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the five-year lookback for irrevocable trusts in Manhattan?
When you apply for nursing-home (institutional) Medicaid in New York, the agency reviews 60 months of financial records before your application. Assets transferred to a Medicaid asset protection trust during that window create a penalty period, so a MAPT must generally be funded at least five years before you need care to fully protect the assets.
Can I put my Manhattan co-op into an irrevocable trust?
Yes, but the co-op corporation’s board must approve the transfer of shares into the trust. Many Manhattan boards have specific trust requirements or restrictions, so board approval should be secured before funding the trust to avoid violating the proprietary lease.
Will I lose control of my home if I use a Medicaid asset protection trust?
You give up ownership of the principal — you cannot sell the home and keep the cash personally — but a properly drafted MAPT typically lets you retain a life estate, the right to live there, the right to trust income, and the power to decide who ultimately inherits.
Do irrevocable trusts avoid probate in New York County?
Yes. Assets properly titled in a funded irrevocable trust pass outside probate, so your family avoids a proceeding in the New York County Surrogate’s Court at 31 Chambers Street, along with its associated delay and expense.
What is the difference between a MAPT and an ILIT?
A Medicaid asset protection trust protects your home and savings from long-term-care spend-down after the five-year lookback. An irrevocable life insurance trust owns a life insurance policy so the death benefit is excluded from your taxable estate, providing tax-free liquidity to pay estate taxes.
Can an irrevocable trust ever be changed in New York?
Under EPTL § 7-1.9, an irrevocable trust can be amended or revoked only with the written, acknowledged consent of every person beneficially interested in it — meaning all beneficiaries must agree, which is why these trusts are treated as a genuine relinquishment of control.
Should I put my IRA or 401(k) into an irrevocable trust?
Generally no. Transferring a retirement account into an irrevocable trust is treated as a withdrawal and triggers immediate income tax on the full balance. Retirement accounts are usually handled through beneficiary designations rather than trust funding.
How does an irrevocable trust help with New York's estate-tax cliff?
New York’s estate tax has a cliff: exceeding the roughly $7.16 million 2026 exemption by more than 5% makes the entire estate taxable. An ILIT keeps life insurance proceeds out of the taxable estate, helping a Manhattan family stay under the threshold and avoid losing the exemption entirely.
Have a question about your estate?
Talk it through with Russel Morgan — free 30-minute consult.